How to Pick the Best Weight Plates for Your Gym

By: Aimee Heckel
Updated On: May 10, 2024
Lifter holding a weight plate

All weight plates are not for all lifters. The perfect style for you depends on your individual goals.  

A typical recreational lifter might not care. And if you’re just starting out or on a budget, any plates are better than no plates.  

But if you want to make an informed decision, here’s a look at how REP’s weight plates differ in terms of material, weight tolerance, size, and other features, and how to pick the right style for your home or commercial gym.  

The Different Types of Weight Plates 

There are several types of weight plates:  

Iron plates  

Man putting an iron plate on a barbell

Iron plates are just what they sound like: the hard, iron weight plates that make clanking noises and that satisfying, sharp, sliding sound when you load them onto your barbell. Iron plates are those classic, old-school circles. They’re usually silver or black. There are different types of iron plates.    

Bumper Plates 

Lifter putting a bumper onto a barbell

Bumpers are rubber-coated plates that can be black but are also frequently multi-colored. These typically have a steel core surrounded by a thick, high-density, rubber coating (not to be confused with the thin coating you may find on irons to protect them from scratches).  You can find a variety of fun bumpers of different colors, patterns, and styles.  

Learn more about the difference between iron plates and bumper plates here. 

Fractional/Change Plates 

Change plates on a barbell

Change Plates and Fractional Plates (also called micro plates) are lightweight plates to add to your barbell for tiny jumps. For bigger, compound lifts like deadlift, the smaller Fractional Plates may not always be useful, but the ability to make a wee jump on upper body lifts -- like bench press, barbell curls, power cleans, or overhead press -- can make a huge difference.   

Learn more about the difference between fractional plates and change plates here.  

A Look at the Different Kinds of Weight Plates 

Here's a closer look at the different kinds of weight plates, comparing their material, weight range, benefit, weight tolerance (that's how accurate the weight is; a lower tolerance is more accurate), and other distinguishing features. 

 

Weight Plate Comparison Chart

Weight Plate Comparison Chart

Weight Plate Comparison Guide

Pick Your Plates

Old School Iron PlatesOld School Iron Plates 

Material: Iron with matte finish 

Weight Range: 2.5-45lbs  

Benefit: Cost effective, classic 

Tolerance: 3% 

Other Features: Marked in both lbs and kgs; lip for maneuverability  

 

USA-Made Equalizers

USA-Made Equalizer™ iron plates

Material: Cast iron finished with premium metallic black E-coat 

Weight Range: 2.5-45lbs  

Benefit: Highest-quality, cast-iron Olympic plates, made in USA, symmetrical grip holes 

Tolerance: 2% 

Other features: Attention to detail, machine-drilled center hole for tight fit 


 Rubber-Coated Olympic PlatesRubber-Coated Olympic Plates 

Material: Iron with rubber coating 

Weight Range: 2.5-45lbs 

Benefit: Coating adds protection 

Tolerance: 3% 

Other Features: Grip holes, attractive details 

 Urethane-Coated IronsUrethane-coated Equalizer™ plates 

Material: Iron with commercial-grade urethane coating 

Weight Range: 2.5-45lbs 

Benefit: Premium, ultra durable 

Tolerance: 3%  

Other Features: Grip holes, high-end finishes 

 Black Bumper PlatesBlack Bumper Plates (LB/KG) 

Material: Rubber coating with steel inserts 

Weight Range: 10-45lbs or 5-20kg 

Benefit: Low bounce, durable, low tolerance (high accuracy) 

Tolerance: 1% 

Other Features: Extra thick 10lb plates to reduce bending 

Color Bumper PlatesColor Bumper Plates (LB/KG) 

Material: Rubber coating with weighted steel center 

Weight Range: 10-55lbs or 5-25kg 

Benefit: Colored per IWF standards, low tolerance 

Tolerance: 1% 

Other Features: Extra thick 10lb/5kg plates to reduce bending and thinner 45lb/20kg to fit more on bar 

Animal PlatesAnimal Print Bumper Plates 

Material: Rubber coating with hooked steel insert 

Weight Range: 10-55lbs 

Benefit: Animal print pattern, aesthetic, low tolerance 

Tolerance: 1% 

Other Features: Extra thick 10lb plate to reduce bending, low bounce 

Competition Bumper Plates (LB/KG) 

Material: Rubber coating with zinc-coated steel disc insert 

Weight Range: 25-55lbs or 10-25kg 

Benefit: Top tier, most accurate tolerance, extra inner steel ring 

Tolerance: 0.25% 

Other Features: Color coded per IWF standards 

Lifter with Pinnacle PlatesPinnacle  plates 

Material: Crumb rubber with steel insert 

Weight Range: 10-55lbs 

Benefit: Softer bounce, extra durable 

Tolerance: 1% 

Other Features: Color-coded fleck with aesthetic mountain design  

 Technique PlatesTechnique Plates 

Material: Hard plastic 

Weight Range: 5lb or 2.5kg 

Benefit: Light weight but same diameter as regular bumpers 

Tolerance: 3% 

Other Features: Black weight markings  

 Hi-Temp Bumpers

Hi-Temp Bumper Plates 

Material: Recycled, vulcanized rubber with stainless-steel insert 

Weight Range: 5-45lbs 

Benefit: Environmentally friendly, made in USA 

Other Features: Stronger than traditional rubber 

 Sport Bumper PlatesSport Bumper Plates 

Material: Rubber coating with steel inserts 

Weight Range: 10-55lbs 

Benefit: Quieter than standard bumpers 

Tolerance: 3% 

Other Features: Textured edges, IWF color, low bounce 

 Fracitional plateFractional Plates (LB/KG) 

Material: Steel with powder coating 

Weight Range: 0.25-1lb or 0.25-1kg 

Benefit: Allow small weight jumps 

Tolerance: 3% 

Other Features: Color coded, laser-engraved markings 

Change PlatesChange Plates 

Material: Rubber coating with metal insert 

Weight Range: 1.25-10lbs or 0.5-5kg 

Benefit: Allow small weight jumps with high accuracy 

Tolerance: 1% 

Other Features: Color coded with raised markings 

NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

Product launch information, promotions, blogs, and REP news.